As teorias retributivas no pensamento anglo-americano contemporâneo
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.46274/1809-192XRICP2019v4p15-57Keywords:
Retribuição, Teorias da pena, Pena, Deontologismo., Consequencialismo, Filosofia analíticaAbstract
Apesar de seu “ressurgimento” nos últimos anos, a teoria da retribuição é rechaçada praticamente de imediato pela opinião dominante na Alemanha, em razão de uma equiparação com as teorias da pena do idealismo alemão. Entretanto, esse posicionamento ignora o desenvolvimento que a teoria da retribuição teve nos últimos anos, especialmente no âmbito de discussão anglo-saxão. Neste trabalho, será apresentada esta última discussão, com o intuito de demonstrar que a teoria da retribuição é muito mais complexa e refinada do que acredita a opinião dominante alemã.
References
ARMSTRONG, K. G., “The Retributivist Hits Back”, em Mind, n.º 70, 1961.
BAGARIC, Mirko/AMARASEKARA, Kumar, “The Errors of Retributivism”, em Melbourne Univeristy Law Review, n.º 24, 2000.
BAURMANN, Michael, Folgenorientierung und subjektive Verantwortlichkeit, Baden-Baden, Nomos, 1981.
BEDAU, Hugo Adam, “Retribution and the theory of punishment”, em The Journal of Philosophy, n.º 75, 1978.
BENN, Stanley Isaac, “An Approach to the Problems of Punishment”, em Philosophy, n.º 33, 1958.
BENTHAM, Jeremy, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, 1907.
BRAITHWAITE, John; PETTIT, Philip, Not Just Deserts: A Republican Theory of Criminal Justice, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1990.
BURGH, Richard, “Do the guilty deserve punishment?”, em The Journal of Philosophy, n.º 79, 1982.
CHRISTOPHER, Russell, “Deterring Retributivism: The Injustice of ‘Just’ Punishment”, em Northwestern University Law Review, n.º 96, 2002.
COTTINGHAM, John, “Varieties of retribution”, em The Philosophical Quarterly, n.º 29, 1979.
DAVIS, Michael, “Criminal Desert and Unfair Advantage”, em Law and Philosophy, n.º 12, 1993.
DOLINKO, David, “Some thoughts about retributivism”, em Ethics, n.º 101, 1991.
______. “Retributivism, Consequentialism, and the Intrinsic Goodness of Punishment”, em Law and Philosophy, n.º 16, 1997.
DUBBER, Markus, Einführung in das US-amerikanische Strafrecht, Munique, C.H. Beck, 2005.
______. “The Unprincipled Punishment of Repeat Offenders: A Critique of California’s Habitual Criminal Statute”, em Stanford Law Review, n.º 43, 1990.
______. Victims in the War on Crime: The Use and Abuse of Victim’s Right, New York, NYU Press, 2002.
DUFF, R. Antony, Punishment, Communication and Community, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011.
______. “Responsibility, Restoration, and Retribution”, em TONRY, Michael (ed.), Retributivism Has a Past, Has it a Future?, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001.
EWING, Alfred C., The Morality of Punishment with Some Suggestions for a General Theory of Ethics, Routledge, 1929.
FEINBERG, Joel, Doing and Deserving: Essays in the Theory of Responsibility, New Jerset, Princeton University Press,1970.
______. “The classic debate”, em FEINBERG, Joel/COLEMAN, Jules (eds.), Philosophy of Law, Belmont, Wadsworth, 7.ª ed. 2004.
FERRAJOLI, Luigi, Direito e Razao: Teoria do Garantismo Penal (trad. ZOMER SICA et al.), 3.ª ed., São Paulo, Revista dos Tribunais, 2010.
FINNIS, John, “The Restoration of Retribution”, em Analysis, n.º 32, 1972.
FLETCHER, George, “Utilitarismus und Prinzipiendenken im Strafrecht”, em Zeitschrift für die gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft, n.º 101, 1989.
FRISCH, Wolfgang, “Schwächen und berechtigte Aspekte der Theorie der positiven Generalprävention”, em SCHÜNEMANN et al. (eds.), Positive Generalprävention. Kritische Analysen im deutsch-englischen Dialog, Heidelberg, C.F. Müller, 1998.
GARDNER, Martin R., “The Renaissance of Retribution”, em Wisconsin Law Review, 1976.
GARLAND, David, The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2001.
GOLDMAN, Alan H., “Toward a new theory of punishment”, em Law and Philosophy, n.º 1, 1982.
GRECO, Luís, Lebendiges und Totes in Feuerbachs Straftheorie: Ein Beitrag zur gegenwärtigen strafrechtlichen Grundlagendiskussion, Berlim, Duncker & Humblot, 2009.
______. “A Ilha de Kant”, em ÍDEM; MARTINS, Antonio (eds.), Direito penal como crítica da pena. Estudos em homenagem a Juarez Tavares por seu 70.º Aniversário em 2 de setembro de 2012, São Paulo, Marcial Pons, 2012.
GREENAWALT, Kent, “Punishment”, em Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, n.º 74, 1983.
HAMPTON, Jean, “The moral education theory of punishment”, em Philosophy & Public Affairs, n.º 13, 1984.
______. “An Expressive Theory of Retribution”, em CRAGG, Wesley (ed.), Retributivism and its Critics, Wiesbaden, Franz Steiner Verlag, 1990.
______. “Liberalism, retribution and criminality”, em COLEMAN, Jules; BUCHANAN, Allen (eds.), In Harm’s way: Essays in honor of Joel Feinberg, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1994.
______. “The Intrinsic Worth of Persons: Contractarianism in Moral and Political Philosophy”, em FARNHAM, Daniel (ed.), The Intrinsic Value of Persons: Contractarianism in Moral and Political Philosophy, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2007.
HART, Herbert Lionel Adolphus, “Prolegomenon to the Principles of Punishment”, em Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, n.º 60, 1959.
HENKE, Martin, Utilitarismus und Schuldprinzip bei der schuldunabhängigen Strafe im angelsächsischen Rechtskreis, Bonn, tesis doctoral, 1990.
HOERSTER, Norbert, Muss Strafe sein? Positionen der Philosophie, Munique, C.H. Beck, 2012.
HONDERICH, Ted, Punishment: The Supposed Justifications Revisited, Londres, Pluto Press, 2006.
HÖRNLE, Tatjana, Straftheorien, Tubinga, Mohr Siebeck, 2011.
______. “Claus Roxins straftheoretischer Ansatz”, em HEINRICH, Manfred;JÄGER, Christian; SCHÜNEMANN, Bernd (eds.), Festschrift für Claus Roxin zum 80. Geburtstag, Berlim, Walter de Gruyter, 2011.
HUSAK, David, “Why Punish the Deserving?”, em Nous, n.º 26, 1992.
______. “Retribution in Criminal Theory”, em San Diego Law Review, n.º 37, 2000.
______. “Holistic Retributivis”, em California Law Review, n.º 88, 2000.
______. “Malum Prohibitum and Retributivism” em DUFF, Antony;GREEN, Stuart (eds.), Defining Crimes: Essays on the Special Part of Criminal Law, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005.
______. “Why Criminal Law: A Question of Content?”, em Criminal Law and Philosophy, n.º 2, 2008.
______. “Broad Culpability and the Retributivist Dream”, em Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, n.º 9, 2012.
______. Retributivism in Extremis, 2012.
JESCHECK, Hans-Heinrich;WEIGEND, Thomas, Lehrbuch des Strafrechts: Allgemeiner Teil, 5.ª ed., Berlim, Duncker & Humblot, 1996.
JOECKS, Wolfgang, em JOECKS, Wolfgang; MIEBACH, Klaus (eds.), Münchener Kommentar zum Strafgesetzbuch: StGB, t. 1, Munique, C.H. Beck, 2011.
KAISER, Hanno, Widerspruch und harte Behandlung, Berlim, Duncker & Humblot, 1999.
KANT, Immanuel, Die Metaphysik der Sitten, t. VIII, Berlim, Suhrkamp, 1997, p. 453 [La metafísica de las costumbres [trad. Adela CORTINA ORTS e Jesús CONILL SANCHO], Madrid, Tecnos, 1996.
KAPLOW, Louis; SHAVELL, Steven, Fairness versus Welfare, Cambridge MA, Harvard University Press, 2002.
KLEINIG, John, Punishment and Desert, La Haya, Springer,1973.
KLOCKE, Gabriele; MÜLLER, Henning, “Zur Renaissance der Vergeltung – Ringpublikationsprojekt ‘Prävention und Zurechnung - Präventionsorientierte Zurechnung?’”, em Strafverteidiger, n.º 9, 2014.
KORIATH, Heinz, “Über Vereinigungstheorien als Rechtfertigung staatlicher Strafe”, em Jura, 1995.
LÜDERSSEN, Klaus, “Muss Strafe sein?”, en HERZOG, Felix et al. (eds.), Festschrift für Winfried Hassemer zum 70. Geburtstag, Heidelberg, C.F. Müller, 2010.
MABBOTT, John D., “Punishment”, em Mind. New Series, n.º 48, 1939.
MACKIE, John, “Morality and the retributive emotions”, em Criminal Justice Ethics, n.º 1, 1982.
MAÑALICH, Juan Pablo, “Retribucionismo consecuencialista como programa de ideología punitiva” em InDret, n.º 2, 2015.
MARKEL, Dan, “What Might Retributive Justice Be? An Argument for the Confrontational Conception of Retributivism”, em WHITE, Mark (ed.), Retributivism: Essays on Theory and Policy, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011.
MARTINSON, Robert, “What works? - questions and answers about prison reform”, en The Public Interest, n.º 35, 1974.
MATRAVERS, Matt, “Is Twenty-first Century Punishment Post-desert?”, em TONRY, Michael (ed.), Retributivism Has a Past: Has it a Future?, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011.
MCCLOSKEY, H. J., “A non-utilitarian approach to punishment”, em BAYLES, Michael D. (ed.), Contemporary Utilitarianism, Gloucester, Peter Smith, 1968.
______. “‘Two Concepts of Rules’—A Note”, em The Philosophical Quarterly, n.º 22, 1972.
MOORE, Michael, Placing Blame: A Theory of the Criminal Law, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1997.
______. Objectivity in Ethics and Law, Farnham, Ashgate, 2004.
MOORE, George Edward, Principia Ethica, Revised Edition, Cambridge, University Press, 1993.
MORRIS, Herbert, “Persons and Punishment”, em The Monist, n.º 52, 1968.
______. “A Paternalistic Theory of Punishment”, em The Philosophical Quarterly, n.º 18, 1981.
MURPHY, Jeffrie, Retribution, Justice and Therapy: Essays in the Philosophy of Law, Dordrecht, D. Reidel, 1979.
______. Retribution Reconsidered, Springer, 1992.
______. “The State’s Interest in Retribution”, en Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues, n.º 5, 1994.
NEUMANN, Ulfrid; SCHROTH, Ulrich, Neuere Theorien von Kriminalität und Strafe, Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1980.
NOZICK, Robert, Anarchy, State, and Utopia, New York, Basic Books 1974.
PAWLIK, Michael, Das Unrecht des Bürgers, Tubinga, Mohr Siebeck, 2012.
______. Person, Subjekt, Bürger, Berlim, Duncker & Humblot, 2004.
PÉREZ BARBERÁ, Gabriel, “Problemas y perspectivas de las teorias expre-́ sivas de la pena”, em InDret, n.º 4, 2014.
PIEROTH, Bodo; SCHLINK, Bernhard, Grundrechte - Staatsrecht II, 27.ª ed., Heidelberg, C.F. Müller, 2011.
PRIMORATZ, Igor, Justifying Legal Punishment, Humanity Books, 1989.
QUINTON, Anthony, “On punishment”, em Analysis, n.º 14, 1954.
RAWLS, John, “Two concepts of rules”, em The Philosophical Review, n.º 64, 1955.
______. Teorías sobre la Ética, México, Fondo de cultura económica, 1974.
ROSEBURY, Brian, “Moore’s Moral Facts and the Gap in the Retributive Theory”, em Criminal Law and Philosophy, n.º 5, 2011.
ROXIN, Claus, Strafrecht. Allgemeiner Teil, t. I, 4.ª ed., Munique, C.H. Beck, 2006.
______. “Strafe und Strafzwecke in der Rechtsprechung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts”, em HASSEMER, Winfried et al. (eds.), In Dubio pro Libertate: Festschrift für Klaus Volk zum 65. Geburtstag, Munique, C.H. Beck, 2009.
SADURSKI, “Theory of punishment, social justice, and liberal neutrality”, em Law and Philosophy, n.º 7, 1988.
SCHÜNEMANN, Bernd, “Aporien der Straftheorie in Philosophie und
Literatur - Gedanken zu Immanuel Kant und Heinrich von Kleist”, em PRITTWITZ, Cornelius et al. (eds.), Festschrift für Klaus Lüderssen, Baden-Baden, Nomos, 2002.
______. “Die Entwicklung der Schuldlehre in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland”, em HIRSCH, Hans Joachim/WEIGEND, Thomas (eds.), Strafrecht und Kriminalpolitik in Japan und Deutschland, Berlim, Duncker & Humblot, 1989. ______. “Die Funktion des Schuldprinzips im Präventionsstrafrecht”, em ÍDEM (ed.), Grundfragen des modernen Strafrechtssystems, Berlim, Walter de Gruyter, 1984.
______. “Zum Stellenwert der positiven Generalprävention in einer dualistischen Straftheorie,”, em ÍDEM et al. (eds.), Positive Generalprävention. Kritische Analysen im deutsch-englischen Dialog, Heidelberg, C.F. Müller, 1998.
SHER, George, Desert, Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1987.
SHAFER-LANDAU, Russ, “The Failure of Retributivism”, em Philosophical
Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition, n.º 82, 1996.
STRATENWERTH, Günter/KUHLEN, Lothar, Strafrecht. Allgemeiner Teil, 6.ª ed., Munique, Vahlen, 2011.
TEIXEIRA, Teoria da aplicação da pena: Fundamentos de determinação judicial da pena proporcional ao fato, 2015.
TEN, Chin Liew, Crime, Guilt and Punishment: A Philosophical Introduction, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1987.
TONRY, Michael “Thinking about punishment”, em ÍDEM (ed.), Why Punish: A Reader on Punishment, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011.
VON HIRSCH, Andrew, Censure and Sanctions, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1993.
VON HIRSCH, Andrew, Fairness, Verbrechen und Strafe: Strafrechtstheoretische Abhandlungen, Berlim, Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag, 2005.
VON HIRSCH, Andrew; HÖRNLE, Tatjana, “Positive Generalprävention und Tadel”, em SCHÜNEMANN et al. (eds.), Positive Generalprävention. Kritische Analysen im deutsch-englischen Dialog, Heidelberg, C.F. Müller, 1998.
WALKER, Nigel, “Modern Retributivism”, em GROSS, Hyman; HARRISON, Ross (eds.), Jurisprudence: Cambridge Essays, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1992.
WHITMAN, James, “A Plea against Retributivism”, em Buffalo Criminal Law Review, n.º 7, 2004.
ZAIBERT, Leo, Punishment and Retribution, London, Routledge, 2006.
ZIFFER, Patricia, “Acerca del ‘resurgimiento’ del retribucionismo” em En Letra Derecho Penal, n.º 6, 2018.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Revista ICP
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
